After submission of doctoral thesis - PhD
Norsk versjon: Etter innlevering
The process once you have handed in your doctoral thesis will depend on your faculty even though the rules and regulations are similar. For specific information on what to do and expect, look at your faculty’s web page. There is some general information below.
Faculty of Architecture and Design
Faculty of Engineering
Faculty of Humanities
Faculty of Information Technology and Electrical Engineering
Faculty of Medicine and Health Sciences
Faculty of Natural Sciences
Faculty of Social and Educational Sciences
Faculty of Economics and Management
Assessment Committee #
Once you have submitted your thesis, the Faculty will appoint an assessment committee based on a suggestion by the Department.
Within one week of being notified of the composition of the committee, you may submit written comments to the composition.
The assessment committee’s work #
The thesis is sent to the committee with a deadline of approx. three months for them to evaluate the thesis. The committee’s job is to evaluate the thesis against the requirements of the PhD-regulations. The Guidelines for the assessment of Norwegian doctoral degrees may also aid the committees in their work.
The committee can make the following recommendations:
- The thesis is worthy of public defence
- Minor revisions
- Not worthy of defence
The Faculty makes the final decision on whether the thesis is worthy of being defended for the doctoral degree, but the Faculty will generally follow the committee’s recommendations. If the committee’s decision is non-unanimous, the Faculty will usually follow the majority decision. For more information about the Faculty’s options, see Section 16 of the PhD-regulations. As the candidate, you may submit written comments to the committee’s report within 10 working days of receiving the report.
If the committee and the Faculty allows minor revisions of the thesis, you will be given a deadline normally not exceeding three months to revise the thesis in accordance with the recommendations. The thesis must be resubmitted by the deadline and the evaluation completed by the same committee. This counts as one assessment in total. The committee should not recommend minor revisions if it finds that extensive changes related to the theory, hypothesis, material or methods used in the thesis are needed in order to deem the thesis worthy of a public defence.
If the Faculty decides that the thesis is not worthy of public defence, you will still be given the opportunity to resubmit the thesis after a waiting period of six months. The decision letter will specify when you are allowed to hand in a revised thesis. A doctoral thesis may only be reassessed once. If your thesis is found not worthy a second time, you will not be able to resubmit the work for the doctoral degree again.
Errata list #
An errata list is a list of formal errors that are corrected in the thesis between submission and the final version. You are not allowed to make any changes or correct anything of a substantial nature. The errata list should be submitted to the faculty prior to the work being made public. Correction of formal errors may only take place once.
Approved thesis #
Once your thesis has been approved, it is time to prepare the defence. The doctoral defence should take place within two months of the Faculty approving the thesis.
Printing your thesis #
The Faculty or Department determines the number of copies to be printed. The thesis should be publically available no later than three weeks before the defence takes place.
Trial Lecture and Disputation #
The trial lecture and the defence usually takes place on the same day.
The trial lecture must be approved before the defence takes place.
Trial lecture #
You will be given the topic of the trial lecture 10 working days before it is scheduled to take place. The assessment committee specifies the topic for the trial lecture and the topic must not have a direct connection to the topic of the thesis.
The purpose of the trial lecture is to test your ability to acquire knowledge beyond the topic of the thesis and to impart this knowledge in a lecture setting. As a general rule, the trial lecture should be structured as to be accessible to an audience with knowledge of the subject that can be expected among advanced students (with at least one year of study in the academic field).
The trial lecture should usually be held in the same language as the doctoral thesis, unless the Faculty approves the use of another language.
Required for dr.philos. #
Dr.philos. has two trial lectures:
- One on the given topic – as described above.
- One self-chosen topic.
The candidate states the title of the self-chosen trial lecture to the faculty four (4) weeks ahead of the disputation.
Both trial lectures must be approved before the defence takes place.
The defence is chaired by the Dean or by a person authorized by the faculty. The chair opens the defence usually followed by the candidate explaining the purpose and results of the doctoral work. This is then followed by the opposition.
There are usually two opponents, both members of the assessment committee. The first opponent opens the discussion and the second opponent concludes it. Members of the audience may participate in the discussion ex auditorio. They have to notify the chair of the defence within the time limit specified at the beginning of the defence.
The defence should be an academic discussion between you and the opponents concerning the research questions raised, the methodological, empirical and theoretical sources, documentation and form of presentation.
After the defence, the committee reports to the Faculty and concludes as to whether or not you have passed your trial lecture and defence.
After the defence #
The Department or research group sometimes hold a small gathering after the defence, but this varies and is completely up to the department itself.
Doctoral dinner #
Most people want to celebrate the defence with a doctoral dinner. This is a private event so it is completely up to you whether to have a doctoral dinner at all, and where and how it takes place. If you have a doctoral dinner, it is customary to invite the chair of the defence, your supervisor and, the assessment committee. You can get tax deductions for some of the expenses related to the doctoral dinner.
PhD ring #
Once you have completed your doctoral degree and you are interested, you may order and purchase a PhD ring. Only people with a doctorate from NTNU may purchase these rings.
Electronic publishing #
Once you have successfully defended your thesis you can make your dissertation openly available at NTNU University Library through NTNU Open. NTNU Open is NTNU’s archive and publishing service for scientific publications.
Doctoral Awards Ceremony #
Some time after the defence, you will be invited to the Doctoral Awards Ceremony where you receive your diploma from the Rector at NTNU. The Doctoral Awards Ceremony generally takes place twice a year. The ceremony in the spring are for the doctors who completed their degree last autumn and the ceremony in the autumn are for those who completed their degree that spring. If you are unable to participate, you will receive the diploma by mail.
Appeals related to handing in doctoral theses, trial lecture and defence is regulated by Section 23-3 of the PhD-regulations. Details for the grounds of appeal should be sent to the Faculty within in three weeks of being notified of the decision. If the Faculty dismisses the appeal, the appeal is forwarded to the University Appeals Committee at NTNU for a ruling.